mbow30
Spudmeister Supreme
That really doesn't change my point, in the slightest.....for the vast majority of his career Kovalchuk played with linemates Nash could only dream of...
but of course it does raise a very valid question about your point.
you have quite clearly implied that nash's productivity is at least in part a result of the people who he has played with. somebody mentioned that kovalchuk still put up superstar caliber numbers despite playing for a similarly poor team; you noted the fact that despite playing for a poor team he had some superlative linemates (who were, at the very least, much better than nash's).
if that is your argument, then of course pointing out that kovalchuk's numbers did not dip but in fact spiked when the likes of savard, kozlov, heatley and hossa were no longer teammates on the thrashers opens up a hole in your argument that nash's production would increase with better linemates.
the whole point is there was demonstrably no effect on kovalchuk.
it certainly casts doubt on the theory that there is a correlation between a top player's production and the quality of their teammates/linemates.
agreed.
and yet the impact on a guy like kovalchuk was negligible.
same with parise (see: numbers with/without kovalchuk)
same with ricahrds and gaborik.
some guys see a spike, others don't. but the evidence seems to suggest that it has much more to do with situational variables (chemistry with linemates, system), than with talent.
Yes.....Kulemin, Schenn, 1st, Grabo.
imo that is a preposterous overpayment. i think that the returns for carter and richards -- who i have in a similar class as nash (first liners but not elite) -- were massive overpayments, and this is substantially more than either of them garnered.
anyways, respond to the rest but not to this, because we'll have to agree to disagree on this count (and i'm not going to post again about a package.. i've said my piece and you've said yours).
Yes, because I don't mind overpaying for productive talent.....if we can blow $11 million between Komisarek, Lombardi and Armstrong, we can overpay a guy like Nash.
i don't mind overpaying for talent either, but i really don't think nash is of a caliber that you overpay for.
i think he's a good step behind kessel at this point, and kessel was 6 years younger and cheaper to boot, and cost the leafs literally half of what you're proposing.
i also don't know why overpaying for crap makes it also ok to overpay for talent. it is unacceptable to waste that money on taht trio. but that doesn't make it ok to surrender those assets/spend that money on nash.
No one's saying Nash is the final piece......you'd have to work to surround him with quality linemates here as well. And no, I wouldn't have him playing with Kessel.
so then how exactly will he be playing with better players than he has played with on columbus?