• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

That really doesn't change my point, in the slightest.....for the vast majority of his career Kovalchuk played with linemates Nash could only dream of...

but of course it does raise a very valid question about your point.

you have quite clearly implied that nash's productivity is at least in part a result of the people who he has played with. somebody mentioned that kovalchuk still put up superstar caliber numbers despite playing for a similarly poor team; you noted the fact that despite playing for a poor team he had some superlative linemates (who were, at the very least, much better than nash's).

if that is your argument, then of course pointing out that kovalchuk's numbers did not dip but in fact spiked when the likes of savard, kozlov, heatley and hossa were no longer teammates on the thrashers opens up a hole in your argument that nash's production would increase with better linemates.

the whole point is there was demonstrably no effect on kovalchuk.

it certainly casts doubt on the theory that there is a correlation between a top player's production and the quality of their teammates/linemates.


and yet the impact on a guy like kovalchuk was negligible.

same with parise (see: numbers with/without kovalchuk)

same with ricahrds and gaborik.

some guys see a spike, others don't. but the evidence seems to suggest that it has much more to do with situational variables (chemistry with linemates, system), than with talent.


Yes.....Kulemin, Schenn, 1st, Grabo.

imo that is a preposterous overpayment. i think that the returns for carter and richards -- who i have in a similar class as nash (first liners but not elite) -- were massive overpayments, and this is substantially more than either of them garnered.

anyways, respond to the rest but not to this, because we'll have to agree to disagree on this count (and i'm not going to post again about a package.. i've said my piece and you've said yours).

Yes, because I don't mind overpaying for productive talent.....if we can blow $11 million between Komisarek, Lombardi and Armstrong, we can overpay a guy like Nash.

i don't mind overpaying for talent either, but i really don't think nash is of a caliber that you overpay for.

i think he's a good step behind kessel at this point, and kessel was 6 years younger and cheaper to boot, and cost the leafs literally half of what you're proposing.

i also don't know why overpaying for crap makes it also ok to overpay for talent. it is unacceptable to waste that money on taht trio. but that doesn't make it ok to surrender those assets/spend that money on nash.

No one's saying Nash is the final piece......you'd have to work to surround him with quality linemates here as well. And no, I wouldn't have him playing with Kessel.

so then how exactly will he be playing with better players than he has played with on columbus?
 
I don't understand why a guy with the stats he has is expected to fetch a price that is Crosby-like?
He's not that good. He sure as hell is not defence-minded, and for that money if you aren't helping in your end you need to get me 50 goals minimum.
 
but of course it does raise a very valid question about your point.

you have quite clearly implied that nash's productivity is at least in part a result of the people who he has played with. somebody mentioned that kovalchuk still put up superstar caliber numbers despite playing for a similarly poor team; you noted the fact that despite playing for a poor team he had some superlative linemates (who were, at the very least, much better than nash's).

if that is your argument, then of course pointing out that kovalchuk's numbers did not dip but in fact spiked when the likes of savard, kozlov, heatley and hossa were no longer teammates on the thrashers opens up a hole in your argument that nash's production would increase with better linemates.

the whole point is there was demonstrably no effect on kovalchuk.

That's where we differ.....you believe that because Kovalchuk's scoring pace increased over a 49 game stretch as a 26 year old (in the middle of his prime) that somehow eliminates that possibility that he benefited from quality linemates in the past. I don't believe that at all.

I also don't believe Kovalchuk and Nash are comparable, I think Kovalchuk is a superior player, and more capable of creating offense on his own, and is more capable of putting up elite numbers on his own. That doesn't change the fact he played with better linemates throughout his youth, or that I think he benefitted from playing with said players, whereas Nash never had that luxury.


it certainly casts doubt on the theory that there is a correlation between a top player's production and the quality of their teammates/linemates.

not really.



and yet the impact on a guy like kovalchuk was negligible.

same with parise (see: numbers with/without kovalchuk)

same with ricahrds and gaborik.


None of the above have had to play with the kind of shit linemates Nash has had to.....let alone for the amount of time he has.




imo that is a preposterous overpayment. i think that the returns for carter and richards -- who i have in a similar class as nash (first liners but not elite) -- were massive overpayments, and this is substantially more than either of them garnered.

anyways, respond to the rest but not to this, because we'll have to agree to disagree on this count (and i'm not going to post again about a package.. i've said my piece and you've said yours).

I'll only add the only pieces I'd be upset over losing, would be Kulemin, and the 1st.



i don't mind overpaying for talent either, but i really don't think nash is of a caliber that you overpay for.

I do......I also don't think $7.8 is the kind of hindrance on a cap (and more specifically future caps) that others do...



i also don't know why overpaying for crap makes it also ok to overpay for talent. it is unacceptable to waste that money on taht trio. but that doesn't make it ok to surrender those assets/spend that money on nash.

If we can survive overpaying that kind of crap (and significantly overpaying for that crap than we would be for Nash) than we can overpay for talent that will actually help us win games and make the team better.

Also, as I say, I think it would force Burke to be more responsible with cap space, and help alleviate the kinds of mistakes he made with Komisarek, Armstrong, etc.....(not to mention, trading the pieces I mention for Nash, would actually result in us not adding to our cap that significantly, if at all, depending on what was spent to fill those extra roster spots)



so then how exactly will he be playing with better players than he has played with on columbus?


..via Burke acquiring them?.....unless you think we're all arguing Nash would be the pièce de résistance, and Burke would simply stop looking to improve the team, upon making such a move.

(I also wouldn't write off Connolly being a better center for Nash, than anyone he's played with to date.)
 
Because he is the hottest item this trade deadline. Can't really fault Howson for asking for the moon for the biggest comodity available. It's a sellers market this year with the playoff race being so tight
 
I don't understand why a guy with the stats he has is expected to fetch a price that is Crosby-like?


He's likely not "expected to" (at least not by me).....most of this is media speculation, and/or Howson starting off by asking for as much as he can, which is generally how most negotiations start.
 
Wait....Nash has been consistently stuck in the 50-65 point range?

He's basically a .85-1.0 ppg player....who has done this on an absolute island as a one man band.

2002-03: 50gp/39pts
2003-04: 80gp/57pts
2005-06: 54gp/54gp

2006-07: 75gp/57pts
2007-08: 80gp/69pts
2008-09: 78gp/79pts
2009-10: 76gp/67pts
2010-11: 75gp/66pts

Average point total over his 9 seasons: 59pts

So, yes, yes he is a 50-65pt player on average, closer to 65 then 50 but still in that range.
 
Nash decides where he goes. There is be 2 or 3 serious offers for him max. The media knows this (Most anyways), but they like being dramatic and selling the idea of a huge trade at the deadline. Columbus won't get that much for him.

The guy might still very well get traded in the summer.
 
That's where we differ.....you believe that because Kovalchuk's scoring pace increased over a 49 game stretch as a 26 year old (in the middle of his prime) that somehow eliminates that possibility that he benefited from quality linemates in the past. I don't believe that at all.

I also don't believe Kovalchuk and Nash are comparable, I think Kovalchuk is a superior player, and more capable of creating offense on his own, and is more capable of putting up elite numbers on his own. That doesn't change the fact he played with better linemates throughout his youth, or that I think he benefitted from playing with said players, whereas Nash never had that luxury.




not really.[/quote]

but of course it does.

if your argument is that better linemates = better production, and you isolate a particular player and say that his production benefited from the quality of his linemates, you cannot then turn around and ignore the fact that when he no longer had those quality linemates his numbers didn't only not fall appreciably, but in fact increased.

of course that casts doubt on your argument. that is undeniable.


None of the above have had to play with the kind of shit linemates Nash has had to.....let alone for the amount of time he has.

well, i think you can certainly make a case for gaborik.

but the point was really to look at it from the opposite side of the ledger. the assumption is that better linemates = better production and yet the players i listed all saw an appreciable DROP in production when paired with superior players.

I do......I also don't think $7.8 is the kind of hindrance on a cap (and more specifically future caps) that others do...

the pa's concession imo will be to staunch the year cap increases in some way. i do not believe you will see a cap that will continue to appreciate as the nhl's has (going from $39mn to $64mn in 7 seasons) beyond this season.

that aside.... the leafs are currently pressed right up against the cap. they do not have a starting goalie. they do not have a first line C. trading for nash will only give them lessr oom to maneuver under the cap, and fewer assets to peddle to get the pieces that they require more than another winger.


Also, as I say, I think it would force Burke to be more responsible with cap space, and help alleviate the kinds of mistakes he made with Komisarek, Armstrong, etc.....(not to mention, trading the pieces I mention for Nash, would actually result in us not adding to our cap that significantly, if at all, depending on what was spent to fill those extra roster spots)

i don't think that 'improved fiscal responsibility' is a reason to bring in a player, who i don't think anybody here would argue is not overpaid, who would become the team's highest paid player by close to $1.5mn.
 
2002-03: 50gp/39pts
2003-04: 80gp/57pts
2005-06: 54gp/54gp

2006-07: 75gp/57pts
2007-08: 80gp/69pts
2008-09: 78gp/79pts
2009-10: 76gp/67pts
2010-11: 75gp/66pts

Average point total over his 9 seasons: 59pts

So, yes, yes he is a 50-65pt player on average, closer to 65 then 50 but still in that range.

527 career points in 650 career games = 0.81 PPG average = 67 point average / 82 games played.
 
2002-03: 50gp/39pts
2003-04: 80gp/57pts
2005-06: 54gp/54gp

2006-07: 75gp/57pts
2007-08: 80gp/69pts
2008-09: 78gp/79pts
2009-10: 76gp/67pts
2010-11: 75gp/66pts

Average point total over his 9 seasons: 59pts

So, yes, yes he is a 50-65pt player on average, closer to 65 then 50 but still in that range.

If you ignore this year (which has been a cluster**** throughout that entire organization), your assertion that he is a 50-65 player is dopey because he did not finish in that range the last 4 years in a row. In 05-06 he had 54 ... in 54 games.

You also ignore the more important stat for a guy like Rick Nash, that being Goals Scored:

41 - 31- 27 - 38 - 40 - 33 - 32 (18 this year)
 
Forget about this "on pace for" stuff, going by the games he has actually played, he IS a 50-65pt producer, on average 59pts.

So if a player has played three seasons and has a stat line of:

82 GP 82 points
18 GP 18 points
82 GP 82 points

You think that it's therefore acceptable to call him a 61 point player regardless of important factors, such as his production per game? Really?
 
Forget about this "on pace for" stuff, going by the games he has actually played, he IS a 50-65pt producer, on average 59pts.

... uh, no. In the games he's actually played, he's produced like a 67 point player.

People really have trouble with the "on pace" term. They don't get that it's a way to take any player's stats over any number of seasons and put it in the context of an 82 game season, so everyone can understand how good the production is.
 
Yeah I thought we had already established this three seasons ago prior to the Antropov trade, no? This should be ancient history by now, much like the brief save percentage debate.
 
2002-03: 50gp/39pts
2003-04: 80gp/57pts
2005-06: 54gp/54gp

2006-07: 75gp/57pts
2007-08: 80gp/69pts
2008-09: 78gp/79pts
2009-10: 76gp/67pts
2010-11: 75gp/66pts

One of the seasons you highlighted was a ppg season. Another you highlighted he was 19, and scored 41 goals in (tying in the Rocket Richard race if memory serves)

Average point total over his 9 seasons: 59pts

Your grasp of statistics is tenuous at best. I'm going to leave it for someone else to explain, for the sake of the posters who have asked me to be nice in your direction.

So, yes, yes he is a 50-65pt player on average, closer to 65 then 50 but still in that range.

You really need to go back to basics on what is and isn't a useful statistic. I neither have the time nor inclination to teach a class on it at present.
 
Forget about this "on pace for" stuff, going by the games he has actually played, he IS a 50-65pt producer, on average 59pts.

Seriously, we should make people graduate from HFB before we let them post on here. This is some old shit that has been sorted out here years ago.
 
TripleFacePalm.jpg
 
What is so hard about figuring out " the on pace stuff". Take the amounts of points, divide by amount of games played and mulitiply by 82.... not that diffucult to figure out what the guy is producing like.
 
Back
Top