• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I like Lupul a lot. I was just wondering if anyone thought we could get much for him.
 
Trading lupul would be like the jays moving Bautista after his first good year. I get trying to sell high but when a guy is playing like lupul is you have to takebthe chance and keep him.

This team would be in a much better spot if lupul is legit than with whatever they'd get in return at this point. IMO you have to take pthe chance on lupul.
 
Build around Colborne and a slew of first round draft picks. And get rid of the guys having career years. Sign free agents, rinse, repeat. Build a new Detroit Red Wing organization.

That's now how Detroit does things. The build a vet team now to teach the kids that are coming along not sell everyone and throw the kids to the wolves.
 
Last edited:
IMO we should target Chris Stewart and Jeff Carter. Big bodied forwards to play the top 6 and can be had without losing Gardiner.
 
i don't know why st. louis would make a deal to shake things up right now.

and jeff carter's game belies the fact that he's 6'3. if you're looking for a forward with size... look elsewhere.
 
And Nabokov. Our march stretch is gonna be the toughest test yet and were gonna need lights out goaltending to stay afloat.
 
I can promise we won't be getting a goalie. As for Stewart; he is in the dog house in St.Louis and has been playing the fourth line; with a lot or players coming back from injury they will have a log jam.

As for Carter; people forget outside of this year he is good for 30/30. With a cap hit of $5.2 million, contract expires at 36 as oppose to 42; and the likelihood or an increased cap or a period to buy out contracts; this one is a no brainer
 
I know we won't be but sadly at this point it should be no 1 on the priority list. It's a glaring hole in our line up right now that is costing us points.
 
There are several reasons which make it fundamentally wrong to move Lupul ...

1. All our top line forwards are very similar ... some have a better shot, some are faster, but otherwise Kessel, Bozak, Grabovski, MacArthur and even Kadri and Frattin are very similar in a sense they are smallish forwards that rely on their speed and skating to create room for themselves. Lupul is the only exception. I ignored Kulemin cos he's totally sucked this year, but otherwise he's another exception.

2. Most of our forwards are very young and inexperienced, the only forward who has been around and plays a top line role is Lupul. When the going gets tough, guys like Bozak or Kessel can't possibly look for advices from Liles (what does a dman know about forwards going through a slump??), or Armstrong (what does Armstrong know about a slump, since 0G in 10 games still isn't a "slump" to a 3rd line forward)

3. Lupul isn't having a 'career year' because all of a sudden he's over-performing. His per-game production numbers this year are very similar to his career numbers. The only difference this year is he's finally healthy. And his health problems are not necessarily 'chronic' ... I don't expect him to get blood infection every year.

4. Through the recent slump, Lupul has been by far the most consistent and hard working forward. He's part of the solution, not part of the problem.

So no, DON'T TRADE LUPUL.
 
IMO we should target Chris Stewart and Jeff Carter. Big bodied forwards to play the top 6 and can be had without losing Gardiner.
Yeah, though of course I have no idea if he's actually available, Stewart would be my #1 target too. Disagree on Carter though.
 
I like Lups, his ability to carry/protect the puck has been instumental in the point production of our "top line".
 
I don't get why Burke is being so stubborn about the goaltending situation, you'd think he would learn from his bad history of goaltending in Vancouver, but I guess not! Outside of coaching, goaltending is handsdown the leafs biggest weakness, you can't make the playoffs when your 25th in goals against, if were going to make the playoffs, the goaltending situation needs to be badly shored up. Reimer and Gus have both proven they aren't capable this year of running with the ball when it's given to them, its time Burke looks eleswhere for that #1 stud in net.
 
You wonder ...

... what the Canucks of the 90's would have accomplished if they didn't stick with Cloutier till the bitter end
... what the Anaheim Ducks would have accomplished if they didn't already have JSG in the fold, during his prime
... what Boston's picks would become if Burke went out and trade for / sign another NHL goalie to replace Toskala in the 09/10 season
... where Toronto would finish if Burke called up Reimer even 1 month earlier to replace the injured JSG in the 10/11 season

And of course, collectively Leafs nation all wonder if the Buds have enough to make the playoff, while Burke stubbornly sticks with his young goalies ranked 25th in the league, even though external help is just a phone call away and relatively inexpensive.
 
I read the Isles are reluctant to trade Nabokov as they are in contract talks right now with him. Harding is an option but it's tough to say what Fletcher would want.

Not sure who else could be had. I'm sure Homer would gladly give up Bryz though
 
Back
Top