• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

1st line C>2nd line LW with no one to play with

cost of nash>cost of stastny financially
cost of nash>cost of stastny in terms of assets

a nash deal doesnt help you dump a shitty contract, whereas a Stastny one might
 
What scares me is your inability to tell the difference between a game breaking dominant player and Stastny.

Both you and I only have stats to look at...lets not pretend either one of us watches Blue Jacket hockey....honestly...he's not as good as you think he is.

70 pts 1 time in 9 years

This year likely not hitting 60

The excuse you and your kin make for him...is that he has no center....in toronto...he would also have no center ( tim connolly, tyler bozak)

And jesus christ its like you dotn understand the cap hit at all.
 
Both you and I only have stats to look at...lets not pretend either one of us watches Blue Jacket hockey....honestly...he's not as good as you think he is.

70 pts 1 time in 9 years

This year likely not hitting 60

The excuse you and your kin make for him...is that he has no center....in toronto...he would also have no center ( tim connolly, tyler bozak)

And jesus christ its like you dotn understand the cap hit at all.

If you are only using points to base your argument, I hereby rest my case.
 
What scares me is your inability to tell the difference between a game breaking dominant player and Stastny.

game breaking dominant player? rick nash? what a joke.

career 70+ point seasons
Stastny: 3
Nash: 1

career points/82 games
Stastny: 24 G 48 A 72 Pts
Nash: 35 G 32 A 67 Pts

past 3 seasons/82 games
Stastny: 22 G 45 A 67 Pts
Nash: 32 G 34 A 66 Pts

past 2 seasons/82 games
Stastny: 23 G 36 A 59 Pts
Nash: 31 G 34 A 65 Pts

Production wise these are pretty damn similar players... except nash makes $1.2mn more per year, and unlike stastny, wouldn't stand a chance of addressing the big gaping hole up the middle.
 
points points points. meaningless statements.

I want Nash for his size, his play along the boards and his higher upside. Nothing you mention changes anything.

We have several holes to fill, including size in the top 6 and a number one center. One doesn't preclude the other. Fawk, why don't we bring in both of them?
 
so do we trade for a mediocre center for our top line (see Connolly, Tim) or do we trade for a top end winger with size for 1 mil more?
 
so...

concerns salary considerations = meaningless statement

concerns over assets needed to acquire players = meaningless statement

fact that stastny and nash have produced comparably over their careers = meaningless statement

fact that first line winger should not be a priority right now = meaningless statement

fact that stastny addresses a need = meaningless statement

fact that stastny might allow the leafs to unload salary = meaningless statement

you're a great debater.
 
i don't think it's so hilarious. schneider looks like he might be as good of a goaltender as gardiner might of a defenseman.

given how unpredictable goalies are, though... i wouldn't make it.

but compared to other offers we've heard.. that's very reasonable. potential #1 defenseman for potential top notch starting goalie... seems like a fair swap.
 
Back
Top