• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

sometimes i think we just need to realize we don't know as much as we think we do about these prospects. i remember the outrage when we didn't select Filatov who has fizzled out as a prospect. the same outrage when we passed on Puempel who had a very disappointing post draft season. people actually hoping Boston would select Hamilton or Courtier over Ryan Murphy. calling guys like Larson and Murphy the next Lidstrom and Coffey.

im not trying to insult anyone here just put in a little perspective. i know we have a lot of very knowledgeable prospect people here but we have a very good management team thats had a lot of success. have a little faith.
 
I wasn't outraged because we didn't pick one of the couple guys I wanted - I was upset because we traded up to pick literally the last guy I wanted with that pick.

He's yet to do anything to prove me wrong.
 
He has made mistakes along the way but there is a reason he is getting paid millions and we get paid nothing to be arm chair gms
 
Burke has done many things that posters here thought was a bad idea and turned out that way. Not sure why people can have opinions about anything else but when it's draft-related people pull out the "management team knows all" lines.

:shrug

When Biggs does what you all think he might, you're welcome to pull out the I told you sos. I would be more than happy to say I was wrong.
 
He has made mistakes along the way but there is a reason he is getting paid millions and we get paid nothing to be arm chair gms

Yeah, he was lucky enough to make friends with higher-ups in the game. It's an Old Boys Club. Always has been. That says nothing about personal competency.
 
I have no idea whether Biggs will be good or not, that's not even really my point. His sample sizes are small and he's played in leagues that are tougher to evaluate from a statistical standpoint.

When it comes to the draft, I'd think you need base your selections on:

*Upside - Potential to be a 1st liner, 1st pairing dman, #1 Goalie
*Position Scarcity - Centers, Powerforwards, Elite Pucking Moving Dman (types of players that are hard to acquire)

If you're picking at the end of 1st round or in later rounds and there are no "upside" guys left and you're left with players who project into 2nd liners, I'd rather take a chance on a raw player who projects as a powerforward type or a dman with really good puck skills over a guy who projects as a solid 2nd liner or 2nd pairing dman. Even if these "raw" players likely won't be top-end players from a statistical standpoint. Solid 2nd liners and 2nd pairing dman are available every free agency for just cash, they are easy to get. It's a lot harder to get a PF or a dman that excels at handling the puck.
 
If you're picking at the end of 1st round or in later rounds and their are no "upside" guys left, I'd rather take a chance on a raw player who projects as a powerforward type or a dman with really good puck skills over a guy who projects as a solid 2nd liner or 2nd pairing dman. Even if these "raw" players likely won't be top-end players from a statistical standpoint. Solid 2nd liners and 2nd pairing dman are available every free agency for just cash, they are easy to get. It's a lot harder to get a PF or a dman that excels at handling the puck.

What you're saying here goes against every principle that you have ever advocated about using your money wisely in a salary cap system though.

The mantra on here has generally always followed that it's perfectly acceptable to spend lots of money on elite players because of their scarcity and high level of performance. It's perfectly acceptable to pay prodigious money for elite level or upper-echelon talents because of their rarity. When you pay big money for them you are getting your money's worth for their performance.

It's when you make the all-too common and preventable mistake of overpaying for supporting components that you hamstring yourself under the cap. With only a limited amount of money to work with it makes more sense to draft and develop those supporting pieces on a consistent basis so that you have a continual turn-over of cheap, NHL ready talent that can support the more expensive, significantly rarer elite players. You can justify paying a boatload of cash for the latter under the cap, but you will end up in cap hell quicker than anything by paying guys like Komisarek $4.5 million. That's the exact problem you and zeke have always outlined, so why the turn-around here? Do you spend money on replaceable parts or not?

You want those cheap, effective second line forwards and second pairing blue-liners from the draft on a consistent basis. You'll never have to overpay for them if you continually identify and draft them.
 
What you're saying here goes against every principle that you have ever advocated about using your money wisely though.

The mantra on here has generally always followed that it's perfectly acceptable to spend lots of money on elite players because of their scarcity and high level of performance. It's perfectly acceptable to pay prodigious money for elite level or upper-echelon talents because of their rarity. When you pay big money for them you are getting your money's worth for their performance.

It's when you make the all-too common and preventable mistake of overpaying for supporting components that you hamstring yourself under the cap. With only a limited amount of money to work with it makes more sense to draft and develop those supporting pieces on a consistent basis so that you have a continual turn-over of cheap, NHL ready talent that can support the more expensive, significantly rarer elite players. You can justify paying a boatload of cash for the latter under the cap, but you will end up in cap hell quicker than anything by paying guys like Komisarek $4.5 million. That's the exact problem you and zeke have always outlined, so why the turn-around here? Do you spend money on replaceable parts or not?

You want those cheap, effective second line forwards and second pairing blue-liners from the draft on a consistent basis. You'll never have to overpay for them if you continually identify and draft them.

Not at all.

Always draft/sign elite, skilled talent. That's #1.

But if your choice is between your average 50-60ish point 2nd liner and a 40ish point powerforward -- I'm taking the powerforward because they are tougher to get. They are a more valuable asset.

And sports is all about assets.
 
Last edited:
I have no idea whether Biggs will be good or not, that's not even really my point. His sample sizes are small and he's played in leagues that are tougher to evaluate from a statistical standpoint.

When it comes to the draft, I'd think you need base your selections on:

*Upside - Potential to be a 1st liner, 1st pairing dman, #1 Goalie
*Position Scarcity - Centers, Powerforwards, Elite Pucking Moving Dman (types of players that are hard to acquire)

If you're picking at the end of 1st round or in later rounds and there are no "upside" guys left and you're left with players who project into 2nd liners, I'd rather take a chance on a raw player who projects as a powerforward type or a dman with really good puck skills over a guy who projects as a solid 2nd liner or 2nd pairing dman. Even if these "raw" players likely won't be top-end players from a statistical standpoint. Solid 2nd liners and 2nd pairing dman are available every free agency for just cash, they are easy to get. It's a lot harder to get a PF or a dman that excels at handling the puck.

But that's what the entire argument is about.
 
Somewhat, but it's also about a draft philosophy.

The most effective draft philosophy is not to lump the available players into different categories. It's to evaluate them as individuals within a meritocracy and proceed forward on that basis.

I don't like the Biggs pick not because I dislike the philosophy of going after a potentially undervalued player with power forward potential. I dislike the Biggs pick because there are very few examples of a physical player like him having posted such limited offensive totals at his age and then suddenly improving. Everyone seems to want to find the next Lucic, but they fail to take into account that Lucic is one of the biggest anomalies in the history of the entry draft. Not every large, semi-skilled PF type is going to develop into him.
 
You would take the inferior offensive player?

Stats help to determine which players project into solid 2nd/3rd liners -- roles that are easy to fill via free agency.

So, I'd rather gamble on a player with a higher upside, maybe with bigger bust potential, that plays a position that is tougher to fill, over a guy that I can just sign easily in free agency.
 
Stats help to determine which players project into solid 2nd/3rd liners -- roles that are easy to fill via free agency.

You're missing the point.

Again, you and zeke have argued for years that those are the worst type of players to target in free agency because you invariably overpay for them and they are easy to draft and extract performance out of for cheap.

I want no part of having to pay $3.5 million for Colby Armstrong when I can simply draft a player such as Lukas Sutter or Coda Gordon in the third round. I don't want to pay $5 million to Joe Pavelski when I can simply draft a Sebastian Collberg or Pontus Aberg in the first round.

So, I'd rather gamble on a player with a higher upside, maybe with bigger bust potential, that plays a position that is tougher to fill, over a guy that I can just sign easily in free agency.

But his upside isn't that high anyways, that's the problem.
 
Burke has done many things that posters here thought was a bad idea and turned out that way. Not sure why people can have opinions about anything else but when it's draft-related people pull out the "management team knows all" lines.

:shrug

When Biggs does what you all think he might, you're welcome to pull out the I told you sos. I would be more than happy to say I was wrong.

That's not what I said though...just that you have differing opinions on players.
 
Back
Top