MindzEye
Wayward Ditch Pig
I think the only issue I'd take with doing an evaluation that way is that... I would rather a pick show even a glimmer of something even if they also don't turn out. A bunch of these guys were zeroes right off the bat - they weren't even close to worthy picks.
Oh, agreed and I think I argued similarly at the time. I'm just using this to look back at results, not process. I hated the 6'5 defencemen with no skills drafts as much as anyone here and way, way more than Zeke who used to drink Rasanen's bath water.