• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Mathew Knies.....

Yeah and I wouldn't expect him to be as strong defensively either.. Not sure their skating is all that similar either. I still have JVR as my upside comp. But that's with only seeing him play once.. He just reminded me of a young JVR.
Knies definitely has more edge to him but JVRs appeal was his size and how he used his body, similar to how Matthews uses his. JVR was a better skater too.. Definitely more toolsy overall but his lack of drive and edge is what largely held him back. He was supposed to be Rick Nash. In other words they're probably not comparable at all now that I'm typing this out. I'll veer back to Hyman.

So the reason why I was so torn between Hyman and JVR is because he's the perfect hybrid between those 2 players. He has better hands than Hyman and is grittier with a far better motor than JVR but if you combine those 2 players, you get Knies. And that's a damn good player. Clearly the very top upside of what I thought he'd be based on the data analysis that 101 and ME kindly provided on player comps. Zen HL and Youtube LOF have done it again. Props.
 
So the reason why I was so torn between Hyman and JVR is because he's the perfect hybrid between those 2 players. He has better hands than Hyman and is grittier with a far better motor than JVR but if you combine those 2 players, you get Knies. And that's a damn good player. Clearly the very top upside of what I thought he'd be based on the data analysis that 101 and ME kindly provided on player comps. Zen HL and Youtube LOF have done it again. Props.
I mean he looks good and all but it's been four games. Zen brigade should take their own advice and chill a bit, sample size is still tiny. Early returns are definitely very encouraging though.
 
Fair but it’s not like he’s scored a bunch and it may not be sustainable like Lonny Bohonos. He hasn’t scored anything and is still impacting games in a big way.
 
Fair but it’s not like he’s scored a bunch and it may not be sustainable like Lonny Bohonos. He hasn’t scored anything and is still impacting games in a big way.


Yeah, this is the most encouraging thing for me. Reminiscent of when I saw Hyman early in his Marlie and then Leaf careers.

In that I had no idea how much of a scorer he’d be, but it seemed certain he’d be a useful NHL player.
 
I don’t really think I need to chill because I just… haven’t changed my opinion at all after 4 games, it’s still the same opinion I’ve had for the last two years and said consistently. He protects the puck really well and is really good at those plays off the wall where he wins the puck and brings it right to the net. I think he’s like the ideal complementary player especially for us.
I mean he looks good and all but it's been four games. Zen brigade should take their own advice and chill a bit, sample size is still tiny. Early returns are definitely very encouraging though.
 
I mean, solely based on numbers and age one would maybe think that Abruzzese was more "ready" than Knies. Abru never looked this good in a single shift, much less 4 games. As part of the emotional bitch overreaction brigade, I'm already anointing him as a can't-miss clear middle 6er and lovely complementary player and more importantly one with a motor unlike bitch ass JVR. I did have him as the teams best prospect but he has certainly met my "max upside" scenario so far at least this early on in his career. I still don't know how much of a point producer he'll be but I'm not sure I care that much as long as the ice continues to be tilted while he's on the ice.

Agree with HL. No need to chill IMO. You don't fluke out a performance like that in a playoff game against Tampa.
 
I see no similarity with JVR. have to say I don't get that comparison at all.


This was so JVR. The way he uses his body to protect his puck, the hands in tight, the cut in to take it to the net, the offensive IQ to even make this play. Of course, current JVR/late Leaf JVR is completely different than early career JVR. He can barely move now. I'm talking early career JVR here.

And this was Hyman

 
I don’t really think I need to chill because I just… haven’t changed my opinion at all after 4 games, it’s still the same opinion I’ve had for the last two years and said consistently. He protects the puck really well and is really good at those plays off the wall where he wins the puck and brings it right to the net. I think he’s like the ideal complementary player especially for us.
I agree that his current play is validating your opinion, but I'm not prepared to make any firm conclusions about him based on a 4-game sample.

Again, he's looked fucking great. Better than I hoped or expected. But its been 4 games. Lonny Bohonos looked great for 4 games too. Hell pretty sure Geno Malgin looked great his first few games with us. I'm not saying I think Knies will be like Bohonos, I do think Knies will be better, I'm just not ready to fully jump on board the JVR/Hyman + LOCK bandwagon.
 
A couple things we haven't seen him do yet:

- carry the puck on the rush
- score


But my biggest worry about him is gone - he can skate at this level.
also, on this roster we won't likely need him to do much of the former. the latter would be nice though, eventually.
 
Knies appears to lack JVR's finish though. I'm hoping he can develop it over time, he's still fairly young.
Yeah the hybrid means he's better than JVR/Hyman at some things, worse at others.. At least thus far in his career. He hasn't proven to be a pure goal scorer at any level really so I'm not holding my breath on that. The same could have been said about Hyman earlier in his career though so who knows. And hell, JVR too for that matter.

But the guy can skate just fine and impact PLAYOFF games in a positive way at this age, this early in his career. I think I'm comfortable in saying that he's an NHL player.
 
Back
Top