I'm definitely fine with taking a chance on a potentially busted player. What I don't like though is paying full price because of reputation instead of recent production trends/performance. Now, I get where ROR's pedigree is different from your typical deadline gritensity addition, but we definitely paid real close to full price ~60 point O'Reilly. It's paid off massively of course, but I'm still generally wary of that type of additional philosophically.
True, we did pay a ton and we assumed all the risk.
I'm not sure that's necessarily true. Aging curves haven't really changed much
Im less interested in the average again curve and more that of the truly elite…Ovechkin, Crosby, Malkin, but also the Pavelskis, Giroux’s, Benn’s, Kopitars, etc….putting up amazing years in their age 38, 35, 36, 38, 34, 33, 35 seasons respectively. Or even Tavares, Karlsson and Stamkos putting up phenomenal career seasons at 32.
but that’s where my comment fails, because Ryan O’Reilly isn’t any of those guys….so while my comment stands about us needing to move the “wrong side of 30” window out a few years, it’s less about the Ryan O’Reilly types, and more about how we view the degree we should expect Matthews, Marner, Nylander, Tavares, and maybe even Rielly’s offence to drop off in their 30’s versus the common Dom models show.
Maybe I’m wrong tho, and his model didn’t apply standard drop off expectations to the majority of the names listed above…
Also, anecdotally. The grittier the player, the steeper their decline sure looks to end up.
also def true.
Now, in fairness to ROR, his game isn't based on power forward style physicality, so maybe he doesn't belong in that group of typical early decliners, but he's not exactly fast either and losing just half a step could be the difference between Super Elite #2C ROR that we've seen so far and 6 million dollar leaderbeans #3C ROR from ages 32-35.
100%…I want him back badly, but having to match the marker and pay $6m per would be too much for me as well I think.