• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The Breaking Point

More and more Californian players are being drafted in the early rounds of the NHL.

... yet the ratings and income-generation of a bottom-feeding team like ours continues to pay their bills down there.
C'mon. Nothing will magically transform those empty arenas down there into giant income makers. Not even Connor McDavid.
 
If it's up to me, the NHL would have about max 18 teams but I don't have any skin in the game except as a fan.

My point is don't confuse what you want (McD wearing a Leafs jersey) with what the league owners wants. Hell, I'm not even sure why you guys care if the league needs and your needs coincide. Sounds like insecurity to me.
 
we know you don't want it to happen, but just say that. no need to pretend McDavid in a Leaf jersey wouldn't be huge and awesome for the league.
 
More and more Californian players are being drafted in the early rounds of the NHL.

Care to quantify that? I mean, we're talking about a state with the population of Canada. If Gretzky had that big of an effect on the entire culture of California, surely we would see it in other things like attendance, no?

I mean, if we simply look at the words of one of these draftees:

"I don't like to admit it, because I'm a Kings fan, [but] the [Anaheim] Ducks winning the Cup [in 2007] definitely helped the growth [of hockey] in California," said Demko, who is in his freshman year at Boston College. "I haven't lived at home for a couple years now, but every time I go back I am always amazed to see the number of kids playing, the number of triple-A teams we have, It's just great to see."

There are ~24,000 registered hockey players of all minor ages in California. Is that what we''re talking about as a success, even if attributing all of that to Gretzky? So if McDavid goes to Phoenix, we'll consider his impact on the hockey culture in Arizona a massive success if there are 4,000 kids registered to play hockey there in 2040? That's the desired effect of a generational player growing the game in one of these markets?

If in 1993, during the height of the hockey fad in LA, I had told you that the state if California in 2015 would have 24,000 kids registered to play hockey, you would have rightly considered the Gretzky era a complete flop at growing the game in the way most reasonable people would have expected at the time, considering the popularity of the Kings at the time.

Which underlines my overall point. A singular superstar player doesn't build a hockey culture. Far, far more important is access to the games, and building a winning team over an extended period of time.
 
Also worth pointing out that in 1993, NHL was a hell of a lot more popular than it is today. So much for "growing the game."
 
nhl revenue

1993 0.7m
2013 3.7b (+429%)

nfl revenue

1993 1.5b
2013 10.0b (+567%)

nba revenue

1993 1.6b
2013 4.8b (+200%)

mlb revenue

1993 1.9b
2013 8.0b (+321%)
 
Getting back to the Leafs, I just don't see how the culture of the team will change without changing the core. If they continue to swap out peripheral players the results will remain the same.
 
Getting back to the Leafs, I just don't see how the culture of the team will change without changing the core. If they continue to swap out peripheral players the results will remain the same.

The salient point, though I think most here see the truth. The question is how much they can get for the players they are moving out.
 
yeah, culture change should do it.

It's like you deliberately ignore the suggestion made by posters that the Leafs need to both improve the talent level on the roster (i.e. skill) AND improve the leadership (i.e. 'culture change'). It's possible to do both (i.e. when the Leafs brought in Roberts & Nieuwendyk).

Are you going to argue that leadership in sports is irrelevant, impossible to quantify, has no impact on success, etc?
 
Its like bizarro world.

Remember when the guy who brought this core in said it was all about CULTURE CHANGE? the same guy. said the last core had poor culture so brought this new core of super culture in. and now the culture sucks again.

it is idiot speak. LA and CHI would still win cups with Kessel and Phaneuf.
 
It's like you deliberately ignore the suggestion made by posters that the Leafs need to both improve the talent level on the roster (i.e. skill) AND improve the leadership (i.e. 'culture change'). It's possible to do both (i.e. when the Leafs brought in Roberts & Nieuwendyk).

Are you going to argue that leadership in sports is irrelevant, impossible to quantify, has no impact on success, etc?
Yeah, it's kind of irritating how any mention of leadership these days seems to bring cries of "Clarkson", or "Komisarek". It's like people have forgotten that you can have leaders that are also good hockey players. And those, in fact, are the kinds of players you should be targeting instead of plugs who are "good in the room".

Take all of the Leafs vs. Sens series of the past. An edge in goaltending is part of the reason why we won all those series, but the other is that we had tough veteran leaders who raised the level of their play in the playoffs and battled through adversity. Guys like Sundin, Thomas, Roberts, Nieuwendyk & Tucker. The Sens, meanwhile, were led by a bunch of pantywaist chumps who had no leadership and grit, and a tendency to fold when the stakes were highest. Guys like Yashin, Alfredsson, Heatley, Redden.

Today, it's like we're the Sens of yesteryear. Except our guys are even bigger pussies then they were, and unlike those Sens teams, they choke before they can even get to the playoffs.
 
Its like bizarro world.

Remember when the guy who brought this core in said it was all about CULTURE CHANGE? the same guy. said the last core had poor culture so brought this new core of super culture in. and now the culture sucks again.

it is idiot speak. LA and CHI would still win cups with Kessel and Phaneuf.

... but not if Phaneuf was their Captain and / or top defender. That's the point here.
You think swapping Phaneuf for Brown would make no difference in LA's leadership? How about ours?
Sure, adding individuals from the Leafs to the Kings won't change much, but exchange their core with ours, and they'd be lacking leadership too.
Ours, OTOH, would improve by leaps and bounds.
 
Yeah its not just that the Leafs are bad. They've had these epic collapses every single year. Its not just a talent thing. Talent is why they aren;t that good without these epic collapses. But most teams don't go through these on a yearly basis. They have issues beyond simply skating well enough, or having enough good shots.

The issue with leadership is guys like Clarkson can't provide it. It has to filter from the top down. So if you're answer to this team's leadship problems is "rabble, rabble Clarkson", you're missing the point. Trying to find leadership in guys like Clarkson because there is a lack of it among your top players is the issue.
 
Back
Top