• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The Breaking Point

Its like bizarro world.

Remember when the guy who brought this core in said it was all about CULTURE CHANGE? the same guy. said the last core had poor culture so brought this new core of super culture in. and now the culture sucks again.

it is idiot speak. LA and CHI would still win cups with Kessel and Phaneuf.

I don't care what labels you want to attach to it, or what semantics you want to play, but successful teams are built on both skill and leadership.

Again, do you think leadership is completely irrelevant to team building?

I don't think anybody here is saying it is the determinative factor to consider, BUT rather it's just once ingredient in the recipe, and one that's been a glaring deficiency on the current roster.

And it's completely disingenuous to conflate this with an argument about 'intangibles' in the context of a Clarkson/Komisarek/Armstrong signing.
 
crosby malkin letang are great players. are they goid leaders? I dunno. who cares?

are kane hossa and keith great leaders? who the **** knows?

and lmao at anyone who thinks dustin brown is a key to LA's success.
 
crosby malkin letang are great players. are they goid leaders? I dunno. who cares?

are kane hossa and keith great leaders? who the **** knows?

and lmao at anyone who thinks dustin brown is a key to LA's success.
Brown may have the "C" in LA, but Drew Doughty sets the tone. Y'know, the legitimate #1 defenseman who significantly ups his game in pressure situations like the Olympics and playoffs, instead of just wilting away like another supposed "top-pairing" defenseman we're all familiar with.
 
crosby malkin letang are great players. are they goid leaders? I dunno. who cares?

are kane hossa and keith great leaders? who the **** knows?

and lmao at anyone who thinks dustin brown is a key to LA's success.

Pitts hasn't really won much of anything recently either, so I think you can legitimately question the leadership of some of their top guys (Malkin, Letang).

Chicago has that Toews guy.

And LA has Kopitar, Doughty, and Jeff Carter.

And again, are you arguing that leadership is irrelevant in the context of a hockey team?
 
crosby malkin letang are great players. are they goid leaders? I dunno. who cares?

are kane hossa and keith great leaders? who the **** knows?

and lmao at anyone who thinks dustin brown is a key to LA's success.

And Brown, despite declining production, still plays a huge role in what LA does. He sets the tone physically and effortwise, which bleeds down through the rest of the lineup.

Do you think it's a coincidence that the last time the Leafs had success in the playoffs we had Sundin, Thomas, Roberts, Nieuwendyk?
 
I am for getting a jonathan toews.

which has nothing to do with having to get rid of all our current players.
 
I am for getting a jonathan toews.

which has nothing to do with having to get rid of all our current players.

I think you're equating wanting to improve the leadership on this team with advocating for jettisoning the majority of the current roster.
 
It's not one guy leading the way, it's the fabric of the entire locker room, with your core guys mattering more. There is something wrong in the Leafs locker room, immaturity and being too mentally soft. And because these guys have spent so many of their young formative years together, they're entrenched in their habits. I think a change in core personnel is necessary.
 
And Brown, despite declining production, still plays a huge role in what LA does. He sets the tone physically and effortwise, which bleeds down through the rest of the lineup.

Do you think it's a coincidence that the last time the Leafs had success in the playoffs we had Sundin, Thomas, Roberts, Nieuwendyk?


coincidence that last time we were good we had a stud #1 center, an elite goalie, and an elite top defense pair?

no, not a coincidence at all.
 
And all fairly good leaders in their own right. They were all self sustaining and never needed a weekly kick in the pants.
 
roberts and nieuwendyk were not even top 5 most important on those teams.

I don't know. From what I recall, Sundin was hurt for a series and Roberts carried the the whole team on his back.
 
roberts and nieuwendyk were not even top 5 most important on those teams.

They were in the dressing room.
And for the record, it's not JUST Brown. It's the group of them. As I said, replace their core with ours and see if it makes a difference.
 
roberts and nieuwendyk were not even top 5 most important on those teams.
This comment is the height of revisionist history stupidity.

Particularly since, back in those days, you couldn't talk enough about our team's "grit".
 
crosby malkin letang are great players. are they goid leaders? I dunno. who cares?

are kane hossa and keith great leaders? who the **** knows?

and lmao at anyone who thinks dustin brown is a key to LA's success.

Was Sidney Crosby a better leader at 19 than he is in his late 20's?
 
It's funny how you are bought bringing up those Roberts Niewy teams... because if talent were the only thing that matters Zeke, then we should have and would have lost to the more skilled and regular season efforts of the Ottawa Senators.

But we didn't, and yes we can all point to Lalime, but what was said about the Senators was that they lacked leadership, and toughness that the leafs brought in spades into those playoff rounds.
of course talent matters, but talent can be stifled with effort and heart.

You talk about "that you'd love to add a Toews" , and that phaneuf and lupul have the talent, but we have not seen it, so why keep doing the same ol same ol.

It's time to change it up, and if it doesn't work then it doesn't work, but christ, why keep doing the same thing and hope things change. That's dumb.
 
I mean at some point we have to come up with some sort of explanation to explain this team's total inability to deal with any sort of adversity, lack of resilience, etc etc. The way this group of players has completely folded and wilted in each of the past four seasons at various points is really, really concerning.
 
Back
Top