• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The New Division

You're not answering anything. You're making an assumption on why he was sat. If I'm wrong about why he was sat I'd prefer to base it upon something other than your medical expertise on a player you've never treated.

So, you're suggesting that he's not as good as Kostka or Fraser, right? That's why he was sat...not due to not being 100% back to form after injury (especially an injury with a very odd recovery curve, like concussion), but because he's not as good as Kostka or Fraser?

Right, but I'm the one having issues.

Exactly what are you basing your opinion on then? seeing as you seem to think that it's footing is far more secure than what mine is based upon.

Let's hear why a recent 1st round pick coming off of a NHL all rookie team selection wasn't as good as Mark Fraser and Mike ****ing Kostka, this should be good.
 
Yeah, not really sure why the **** you're going on about how he's wrong since he's not Gardiner's doctor though.

It's pretty much common knowledge what happened with Gardiner. Google it.

Definite koreaboy student.

I'm not saying he's wrong. He's saying I'm wrong. If it was that easy to disprove by googling it, why hasn't he done so already? All I asked for was a link to back up what he's claiming.
 
Yes, I'm saying that you're wrong that Fraser and Kostka are better hockey players than Jake Gardiner.

No, I don't think providing links for that is necessary.
 
Can't really decide what's more annoying - having Sens fans come over to tell us about reasons for roster decisions concerning our team or the frequency in which the onus ends up on Leaf fans to provide evidence, stats, links, etc.
 
Can't really decide what's more annoying - having Sens fans come over to tell us about reasons for roster decisions concerning our team or the frequency in which the onus ends up on Leaf fans to provide evidence, stats, links, etc.


Which then they ignore, stop discussing the issue, and bring up the same tired arguments a few months later.
 
So, you're suggesting that he's not as good as Kostka or Fraser, right? That's why he was sat...not due to not being 100% back to form after injury (especially an injury with a very odd recovery curve, like concussion), but because he's not as good as Kostka or Fraser?

Right, but I'm the one having issues.

Exactly what are you basing your opinion on then? seeing as you seem to think that it's footing is far more secure than what mine is based upon.

Let's hear why a recent 1st round pick coming off of a NHL all rookie team selection wasn't as good as Mark Fraser and Mike ****ing Kostka, this should be good.

When the case of Jake Gardiner was raised early in his post-practice discussion with reporters on Friday, Toronto Maple Leafs coach Randy Carlyle delivered his answer before the questioner could finish asking their question.

“He’s got to be better defensively,” Carlyle said sharply. “Simple as that.”


http://sports.nationalpost.com/2013...o-leafs-lineup-rests-on-defensive-refinement/

“I’m not sure what’s going on,” Gardiner said Tuesday. “I feel like I can definitely contribute. I’m going to do whatever the team needs to win. I’m just going to try to contribute any way I can.”


http://www.thestar.com/sports/leafs...leafs_jake_gardiner_struggling_to_fit_in.html

No mention of PCS.
 
Then obviously the answer is that Kostka & Fraser are better than Jake Gardiner, right?


You act like it's crazy that I'm suggesting Gardiner still wasn't in full form from missing significant time with a concussion.
 
Then obviously the answer is that Kostka & Fraser are better than Jake Gardiner, right?

Why else would Carlyle play then over him then?


You act like it's crazy that I'm suggesting Gardiner still wasn't in full form from missing significant time with a concussion.

You act like it's crazy that I'd like to see a link providing evidence of your claims. I never stated that you were wrong. But I'm not going to go on your word alone.
 
Why else would Carlyle play then over him then?

Because Jake Gardiner wasn't in full form yet?


You act like it's crazy that I'd like to see a link providing evidence of your claims. I never stated that you were wrong. But I'm not going to go on your word alone.

You don't need to go on my "word". Jake Gardiner had a concussion, this is well documented. Concussions are notoriously sketchy injuries to come back from and concussion sufferers often take extended periods of time to come back from 100%. Also quite often, players are cleared to play medically after their concussions, but clearly aren't 100% for quite some time after being medically cleared.

If Jake Gardiner passed a baseline test (which he did), why would anyone officially admit that he was suffering from lingering PCS still? There's a long list of players who took a while after returning to the lineup before they found full form after a concussion.

So what's more likely? That a 22 yr old 1st round draft pick and NHL all rookie team member isn't as good as 2 AHL level plugs, or that he hadn't returned to full form from a recent concussion?
 
In fairness, I suspect Ryan will replace Alfredsson. But seriously, Clarke MacArthur is the Sens fourth best scoring option up front right now........but there's no problem with their scoring depth, no.

Ryan exceeds Alfredsson's production. MacArthur at least matches, Conacher, Turris, Zibanejad, Pageau, SDC and Greening are all capable offensive players.

We are fine.
 
according to most he's been clearly outplayed this preseason by Krug and Bartkowski.....even though neither of those two have looked great.
 
according to most he's been clearly outplayed this preseason by Krug and Bartkowski.....even though neither of those two have looked great.

Says who? Bartkowski is leading the league with 6 assists, and Krug has also played well. For all the handjobs Gardiner gets around here, Bart is easily his match.
 
Back
Top