• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Nabokov is simply the only option out there that makes sense at the moment. He's a proven veteran with a long track record of success and has substantial playoff experience.
 
I hope the Leafs get Nabokov and not Schneider.

The Leafs with Nabokov and Gardiner are far less dangerous than the Leafs without Gardiner, but with a goalie as talented as Schneider.
 
So the Leafs with a stud young defenceman and a Vezina calibre goaltender are less dangerous than the Leafs without that stud young defenceman and a career back-up?

Never_47969f_629640.jpg
 
I think both sides of the debate are correct in some ways.

Nash is an exceptional talent and would provide the size, strength, and scoring that we need more of. Trading for him would also deplete our prospect pool by two or three bodies and a pick, in all likelihood, and may interfere with our ability to land a true center.

Thing is, we've had that prospect pool growing for a few years now and haven't been able to use it to land a center yet. No guarantee we'll be able to if we pass on the opportunity to get Nash.

I sort of long for a power forward like Nash, personally. And I think he'll pull a Lupul when he gets here and become a 35 - 40 goal scorer. Plus, he's young, would fit in with this mix, and is from Toronto - tough to not like that.

My vote is for getting him, but of course only for the players I want to part with - Schenn, Kadri, and 1st.

I made the same argument mbow is making now when we were acquiring Kessel. That if we ponied up those picks, we'd be in a tough spot trying to acquire a center to play with Kessel. Naturally, I was right, but now I also think that as star players who'd be good fits and address needs become available, you ought to grab them from time to time.

No one is going to argue that we don't need a crashing, banging, and scoring Rick Nash at his finest. He'd be another core piece to add to the young group of Kessel, Lupul, Kulemin (yes), Phaneuf, and Gardiner. I want that. Guys with 40 goal skill don't grow on trees, and if his time is done in Columbus, he could give us a good 6 years and 200 goals. Can't pass that up for the right price.

Sure, that still leaves center and goalie as our two most glaring holes. But I think we could, and should, get a Nabokov for now and maybe even keep him if it works out. And as for center, who is to say that we don't already have him? Colborne is a guy I am so high on, just like I was with Gardiner the first time I saw him (when others here were all meh about him). I think he could be our answer, regardless of his stats over the past several games. But if not him, there will be centers coming available, just like wingers like Nash and Kessel did, and we just gotta pounce.

Maybe Stastny is that guy right now. Frankly, I like him a ton and would try to bring him in at the same time as Nash, if we can truly get him for cheap and dump a contract like Komi or Lombardi on them.

The Leafs suck ass right now, and I personally blame the goalies and moreso Wilson (what the **** is the system, or lack thereof, that we play, where every player just does what he wants without any plan or play, other than the scripted PP drop pass?). But this is a time of opportunity to buy low on some star players. I liked Carter, who got dumped to the Kings, but here we have the likes of Nash and Stastny, and who knows who else (Stall, the other Stall, Getz?), who might be there for the taking, so we really ought to scrap some players and bring them in.
 
I hope the Leafs get Nabokov and not Schneider.

The Leafs with Nabokov and Gardiner are far less dangerous than the Leafs without Gardiner, but with a goalie as talented as Schneider.

Think you're overrating Schneider and underrating Gardiner pretty significantly.

Also, don't have the stats offhand, but pretty sure Nabby has been either as good or better than Schneider in significantly more playing time this season. They're at least close enough that the presence/absence of Gardiner would easily make up for any edge Schneider may hold over Nabby.

But again you're just fanning some flames, so I won't concern myself too much about this.
 
Not going to lie, the thought of acquiring a goalie and having him dominate for the next 10 years has me intrigued. Schneider does have the pedigree.
 
Hey, you won't see me defend Burke's record on goaltending. Unfortunately, the only good goalie he's ever had (Giguere) he inherited, though I guess he also hit a home-run by signing Hiller (and has been trying to duplicate that feat in Toronto by signing every college and international goalie UFA he can get his hands on, with mixed results at best so far). I don't really see how that relates to this discussion though. Whether you like it or not, Cory Schneider is not a proven star #1 goalie, and the return you get in his eventual trade will reflect that.

No different than Jake Gardiner is not a proven top 4 Dman. Schneider is closer to a legit #1 right now than Gardiner is a top 4 Dman, no?
 
No different than Jake Gardiner is not a proven top 4 Dman. Schneider is closer to a legit #1 right now than Gardiner is a top 4 Dman, no?

I don't know about that, pretty sure Jake is at the minimum our 2nd highest d-man in MPG in 2012, and has produced well enough to justify that. Whereas Schneider has never been a #1 goalie.
 
No different than Jake Gardiner is not a proven top 4 Dman. Schneider is closer to a legit #1 right now than Gardiner is a top 4 Dman, no?
Considering Jake Gardiner has been playing top-four minutes on this team all season and Schneider has never been a legitimate #1 goalie...the answer is "No".
 
No different than Jake Gardiner is not a proven top 4 Dman. Schneider is closer to a legit #1 right now than Gardiner is a top 4 Dman, no?

Gardiner has played more than 25 minutes per game on many nights this season and even eclipsed Dion on several occasions in the ice-time department.

So no.
 
Back
Top