OT: NFL thread
- Thread starter Thurston
- Start date
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
what about 14-21 309 2 TDs 3 INTs?
or 9-14 96 yds and 1 TD
what about 14-21 309 2 TDs 3 INTs?
or 9-14 96 yds and 1 TD
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
Close, his other hero Bradshaw.
Using Wehave's logic, he deserves no credit for at least two of those four wins given his stats were atrocious.
Close, his other hero Bradshaw.
Using Wehave's logic, he deserves no credit for at least two of those four wins given his stats were atrocious.
WeHaveMoreCupsThanYou
I will get banned again soon, worry not.
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
2 of his 9 completions went for touchdowns. Scoring is what it's all about.
2 of his 9 completions went for touchdowns. Scoring is what it's all about.
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
so then it doesn't matter the numbers so why were you ripping on Manning for his SB win, he clearly did enough to score more than the opponent that game.
you know as well as I do if Manning won with a 9-14 96 yard game, you would rip him a new one
You are only defending that number now because you have lauded Bradshaw for years
so then it doesn't matter the numbers so why were you ripping on Manning for his SB win, he clearly did enough to score more than the opponent that game.
you know as well as I do if Manning won with a 9-14 96 yard game, you would rip him a new one
You are only defending that number now because you have lauded Bradshaw for years
WeHaveMoreCupsThanYou
I will get banned again soon, worry not.
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
Bradshaw didn't lose big games
Bradshaw didn't lose big games
WeHaveMoreCupsThanYou
I will get banned again soon, worry not.
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
I would put Manning's post season career on par with, say, Staubach, who won a couple and lost a couple. Regular season Manning is probably top 3 in history.
I would put Manning's post season career on par with, say, Staubach, who won a couple and lost a couple. Regular season Manning is probably top 3 in history.
worm
Well-known member
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
It is hard to keep track of all his favourite teams/players.
It is hard to keep track of all his favourite teams/players.
WeHaveMoreCupsThanYou
I will get banned again soon, worry not.
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
Bradshaw had Franco Harris and Rocky Bleier. He didn't need to pass in order to win games
Bradshaw had Franco Harris and Rocky Bleier. He didn't need to pass in order to win games
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
well according to those numbers, he certainly didn't "win" at least three of his SBs using Wehavian logic. The only one where he had decent numbers was SuperBowl XIII where he only won because Jackie Smith dropped a sure TD.
well according to those numbers, he certainly didn't "win" at least three of his SBs using Wehavian logic. The only one where he had decent numbers was SuperBowl XIII where he only won because Jackie Smith dropped a sure TD.
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
and Manning didn't yesterday either, so what is the difference?
and Manning didn't yesterday either, so what is the difference?
Rolex
Canadiens Moderator
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
Manning was MVP of a SB....Favre never won MVP of a SB.
Manning went to 4 SB....Favre went to 2.
For those who say Eli is more clutch than Peyton, well Eli only took his team to 2 SB...his brother to 4 SB
Which means Favre and Eli were not clutch enough in the playoffs to make it to 4 SB like Peyton
Manning was MVP of a SB....Favre never won MVP of a SB.
Manning went to 4 SB....Favre went to 2.
For those who say Eli is more clutch than Peyton, well Eli only took his team to 2 SB...his brother to 4 SB
Which means Favre and Eli were not clutch enough in the playoffs to make it to 4 SB like Peyton
Rolex
Canadiens Moderator
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
Also, I'm not sure the Broncos win without Manning at QB....the coach and players said that when the decision was made to put Manning back in during week 16 (or 17), it had a calming effect on the whole team. By then, Manning knew how to run the offense to limit turnovers and allow the defense to shine.
He only had one INT since becoming the starter again....
Also, I'm not sure the Broncos win without Manning at QB....the coach and players said that when the decision was made to put Manning back in during week 16 (or 17), it had a calming effect on the whole team. By then, Manning knew how to run the offense to limit turnovers and allow the defense to shine.
He only had one INT since becoming the starter again....
WeHaveMoreCupsThanYou
I will get banned again soon, worry not.
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
It's a semantic argument anyway. Montana is #1 and Brady is #2. Everyone else is bickering over third place.
It's a semantic argument anyway. Montana is #1 and Brady is #2. Everyone else is bickering over third place.
BKerr
Banned
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
Brady chokes when he plays against a Manning in the playoffs, how else do you explain a 2-5 record?
Brady chokes when he plays against a Manning in the playoffs, how else do you explain a 2-5 record?
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
At losing yes. He and Fran Tarkenton hold a special place in NFL lore.
Re: OT: NFL thread (Superbowl 50)
How does the spying and deflating of footballs play into your theory?