• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The Breaking Point

Unless you get an incredible opportunity (and no, not a draft pick), you don't trade Kessel, JVR, Kadri, Rielly, or Gardiner. It may seem odd to include Gardiner in there, but we're never going to get value for him, and there is still a very good chance he improves substantially and reaches his upside.

Then there's a set of players who are very good that would be nice to keep or bring back, like Komarov, Santorelli, Winnik, and Franson. You keep Komarov, but the rest have to dealt for picks, and then make an effort to bring them back in the offseason.

And then there are some you have to deal. Bozak has to go, he just doesn't fit as a 1C or a 3C. Lupul can't be counted on to stay healthy. And Phaneuf is the face of a team that has a terrible complexion, so much as I like him, he has to go too.

But you don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. You're not going to get close to getting the young talent we currently have by trading them for picks.
 
Didn't we beat them every game in the regular season that year?

a whopping two games but no way after going 7 in all your games that you would have won against us, we were well rested, having gone 6, 4, 5 so we had played six games less than you over the same period of time. Hell, there was no guarantee you would have that game in Los Angeles anyway. Furthermore, you had a chance at home to close out the series and screwed that up too
 
I was at game 6 actually. You could see what was going to happen when they didn't give Wayne a penalty. You could smell it. It was weird for sure. And yeah...The Leafs played was too many 7 game series when ever they made the playoffs. The Sens were always the better team but the Leafs beat the crap out of them to get by. Ran out of gas each time.
 
oh my... so much whining.... what a pussies....
how about fans from NY, Columbus, Blues, Wild etc?
Stop embarrassing your self in front of Sens/Habs fans
 
I find it weird that people say I was a fan since XXXX year

Should be a fan since birth. Unless you just moved to Canada that year.
 
I was at game 6 actually. You could see what was going to happen when they didn't give Wayne a penalty. You could smell it. It was weird for sure. And yeah...The Leafs played was too many 7 game series when ever they made the playoffs. The Sens were always the better team but the Leafs beat the crap out of them to get by. Ran out of gas each time.

You had come back in that game from 4-1 if I recall. You had Mo on your side.
 
that the new guys in charge seem to be focussed, yet again, on getting rid of assets instead of on assets to add depresses the hell out of me.

same mistake every new management here makes.

trading everyone for a bunch of midround picks doesn't help a rebuild anywhere near as much as people pretend it doesn

What?

Fiction.

When JFJ came in he followed precisely your line of thinking -- he added to the existing roster the fabled missing pieces. He did not trade a single significant player off the roster during his entire tenure.

The previous GM takeover (Quinn) didn't do anything of the sort either.The same can be said for the current management team (Nonis) -- they also did precisely what you are advocating!

The only management changeover that did what you say happens every time is the JFJ-Fletcher-Burke transition.

You can claim (rightly so) that both Fletcher and Burke made some reactionary/impetuous moves to turnover the roster, but even there we're talking about three players: Steen, McCabe, Antropov. You'd be very hard pressed to claim that Shanahan has done anything reactionary. Shit, he's been incredibly patient with this team.

What no one in modern Leafs history has ever done is to focus on building a team primarily by drafting and developing your own players.
 
Last edited:
Not that it matters much but I have completely checked out. I now have zero interest in hockey and the leafs.

Years ago I was very much into them, watching every game, going to two or three games a year and now Ive moved on with my life and have focused and more important and entertaining things.

Hell I don't even post here much and rarely is it in hockey related threads. I've also noticed we've lost a lot of posters here too, though that may not be directly related to the on ice product.
 
What?

Fiction.

When JFJ came in he followed precisely your line of thinking -- he added to the existing roster the fabled missing pieces. He did not trade a single significant player off the roster during his entire tenure.

The previous GM takeover (Quinn) didn't do anything of the sort either.The same can be said for the current management team (Nonis) -- they also did precisely what you are advocating!

The only management changeover that did what you say happens every time is the JFJ-Fletcher-Burke transition.

You can claim (rightly so) that both Fletcher and Burke made some reactionary/impetuous moves to turnover the roster, but even there we're talking about three players: Steen, McCabe, Antropov. You'd be very hard pressed to claim that Shanahan has done anything reactionary. Shit, he's been incredibly patient with this team.

What no one in modern Leafs history has ever done is to focus on building a team primarily by drafting and developing your own players.

Even on this team -- people act like they need to just sit on players until they get the best trade that they can but sometimes those trades just don't come around (especially with the cap in play), and this team ****in sucks and shouldn't be kept together, anyways... regardless of how talented some here think it is.

This ship is not salvageable. They have a few pieces worth keeping around. That's it.

And the reality with guys like Phaneuf and Lupul is that sometimes you just have to cut your losses (frankly, especially with those two, who are only going to go downhill in their 30s, and could stand to become anchors on the cap).

It is far more important that this team start drafting and developing talent better than they have than that they get a B prospect and a 1st round pick for Phaneuf rather than a C prospect or a 2nd (or whatever the hypothetical trade materializes as).

Frankly, this isn't like with McCabe, who was a key cog on teams that were actually good and whose final years were marred by terrible goaltending. Phaneuf's tenure here has been an abject failure.
 
Last edited:
how does ditching phaneuf and lupul for peanuts hasten a rebuild?

How does continuing to be an 82 point team with them around, taking ice time from young players, developing your young guys in a locker room with guys who have been career losers, and waiting until they're old, even more broken and totally untradeable help anything?

You 'hasten' your rebuild by, y'know, actually rebuilding.

The status quo here is unacceptable. and as much as you want to blame it on the supporting cast, or Nonis, or Randy or whomever, the bottom line is this group has been together for several years, under multiple GMs and coaches, with a host of supporting casts, and has been totally incapable of achieving any sort of tangible success whatsoever.

But, yes, let's just wait it out to get a marginally better return on a trade (which still won't mean a damn thing if they continue to draft and bring players along as poorly as the Maple Leafs have).
 
Even on this team -- people act like they need to just sit on players until they get the best trade that they can but sometimes those trades just don't come around (especially with the cap in play), and this team ****in sucks and shouldn't be kept together, anyways... regardless of how talented some here think it is.

This ship is not salvageable. They have a few pieces worth keeping around. That's it.

And the reality with guys like Phaneuf and Lupul is that sometimes you just have to cut your losses (frankly, especially with those two, who are only going to go downhill in their 30s, and could stand to become anchors on the cap).

It is far more important that this team start drafting and developing talent better than they have than that they get a B prospect and a 1st round pick for Phaneuf rather than a C prospect or a 2nd (or whatever the hypothetical trade materializes as).

Frankly, this isn't like with McCabe, who was a key cog on teams that were actually good and whose final years were marred by terrible goaltending. Phaneuf's tenure here has been an abject failure.

Pretty much totally agree with this.

This team needs to go through a rebuild. I think Shanahan has the patience and vision to do this. I'm very leery of them trading guys for others' prospects and roster players, as Steve Kasper, Penny, Rowie and Watt are still the pro scouting department who have brought us such gems as Clarkson, Bolland, McSelke, Booth, et al. A bit more okay with Mark Hunter heading up that group, but still very nervous about them trading for pros.

If I look at any of the established 25+ year olds on the team, the only ones I'm keen on holding onto are Kessel and Komarov. Even Kessel I'd be okay with unloading if they got a wickedly good return. I'm a bit on the fence about Franson, but he's probably going to demand too much to retain for the rebuild.

That said, there are some good young talented guys on the roster I'd not want to give up on just yet: Kadri, Rielly, Holland, Panik and, yes, Gardiner (!).

The rest ... meh, and a few I'd like to send packing (Phaneuf, Bozak, JVR).
 
Back
Top