• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The Breaking Point

How does continuing to be an 82 point team with them around, taking ice time from young players, developing your young guys in a locker room with guys who have been career losers, and waiting until they're old, even more broken and totally untradeable help anything?

You 'hasten' your rebuild by, y'know, actually rebuilding.

The status quo here is unacceptable. and as much as you want to blame it on the supporting cast, or Nonis, or Randy or whomever, the bottom line is this group has been together for several years, under multiple GMs and coaches, with a host of supporting casts, and has been totally incapable of achieving any sort of tangible success whatsoever.

But, yes, let's just wait it out to get a marginally better return on a trade (which still won't mean a damn thing if they continue to draft and bring players along as poorly as the Maple Leafs have).

you answered every one of your questions at the end there in brackets.

ditching players is the least important of "rebuilding".
 
Part of bringing along players is developing them alongside guys who set a good example on and off the ice.

Phaneuf and Lupul have histories of the exact opposite.

This group of players has been together for several seasons and this team has sucked in basically all of them. Lupul is turning 32, Phaneuf is turning 30. Frankly, their best years are clearly in the rearview mirror and in both cases it looks like the descent into mediocrity has been or will be pretty rapid.

And I don't know what to tell you if you think that Phaneuf earning $7m as a 34 year old #4 defenseman is somehow going to help this team, or have more trade value than he has right now.
 
Poisoned chalice.

Absolutely, you have to have good pros on the roster to bring along the youngsters. Not many players on this roster that will set a good example. In fact, many that will set a bad example.
 
ditching players is the least important of "rebuilding".

i don't care about "rebuilding" so much as i care about "getting better".

these guys have had their chances and they have failed, miserably, every time.
 
We already can't score a goal or win a game. I see nothing to be gained by keeping this core group together. they had their chance to prove this was a good team held back by poor coaching, and have totally failed to do so.

I would be very hesitant to trade Kessel or Rielly/Nylander but anyone else could be had.
 
Part of bringing along players is developing them alongside guys who set a good example on and off the ice.

Phaneuf and Lupul have histories of the exact opposite.

This group of players has been together for several seasons and this team has sucked in basically all of them. Lupul is turning 32, Phaneuf is turning 30. Frankly, their best years are clearly in the rearview mirror and in both cases it looks like the descent into mediocrity has been or will be pretty rapid.

And I don't know what to tell you if you think that Phaneuf earning $7m as a 34 year old #4 defenseman is somehow going to help this team, or have more trade value than he has right now.

ah, so now its CULTURE CHANGE that's needed.

where have we heard that before?
 
What?

Fiction.

When JFJ came in he followed precisely your line of thinking -- he added to the existing roster the fabled missing pieces. He did not trade a single significant player off the roster during his entire tenure.

The previous GM takeover (Quinn) didn't do anything of the sort either.The same can be said for the current management team (Nonis) -- they also did precisely what you are advocating!

The only management changeover that did what you say happens every time is the JFJ-Fletcher-Burke transition.

You can claim (rightly so) that both Fletcher and Burke made some reactionary/impetuous moves to turnover the roster, but even there we're talking about three players: Steen, McCabe, Antropov. You'd be very hard pressed to claim that Shanahan has done anything reactionary. Shit, he's been incredibly patient with this team.

What no one in modern Leafs history has ever done is to focus on building a team primarily by drafting and developing your own players.

you are correct.

neither cliff fletcher (mark 1) nor pat quinn prioritized "cleaning house", despite those teams being awful. instead, they concentrated only on making good moves for good players. they both created great teams as a result - even with many key pieces from those awful teams they inherited.

cliff fletcher (mark 2) and burke, otoh, prioritized "cleaning house" for "culture change" and it got us nowhere. left us spinning our wheels.
 
I think you've been spooked by a repeat of the Fletcher/Burke transition. I see no reason to think it will be happening again. Since Shanahan has taken over the top of the organization, there have been exactly 2 trades and none since July 1st.

They have been patiently evaluating this team with what seems like a better group of execs. No one has said a word about culture change or the blue and white disease.
 
I think you've been spooked by a repeat of the Fletcher/Burke transition. I see no reason to think it will be happening again. Since Shanahan has taken over the top of the organization, there have been exactly 2 trades and none since July 1st.

They have been patiently evaluating this team with what seems like a better group of execs. No one has said a word about culture change or the blue and white disease.

I'm pretty sure Shanny has explicitly talked about culture change on multiple occasions...
 
http://www.nhl.com/ice/news.htm?id=728357

When he was introduced just after the 2013-14 season ended, shortly after an eight-game losing streak took the Leafs out of playoff contention, Shanahan promised a "culture change" for the team. At Thursday's news conference to reveal Ted (Teeder) Kennedy would be the first player honoured as part of the new Legends Row, Shanahan didn't let on about any more grand plans to that end.
 
I'm pretty sure Shanny has explicitly talked about culture change on multiple occasions...

Here's the press conference:

[video=youtube;CNXyv0LRRp0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?x-yt-cl=85114404&x-yt-ts=1422579428&v=CNXyv0LRRp0[/video]

He doesn't say a single thing about culture change during the entire thing. Tim Lewieke, however, says plenty about it. He is, thankfully, not part of the Leafs management group.

Importantly, what Shanahan does say is precisely the opposite of the approach of Fletcher and Burke -- he needs to learn, evaluate, etc., before figuring out what needs to be done. He says this over and over again. And, given what has happened since, he's been true to his word.
 
They have been patiently evaluating this team with what seems like a better group of execs. No one has said a word about culture change or the blue and white disease.

Better group? Remains to be seen.
Certainly Shanny has brought in Hunter and a couple others, but we still have Nonis, and he foolishly kept Carlyle last summer. I don't think a rebuild of the team is a good idea until the rebuild of the front office is done, especially in our scouting dept.
I do think Shanny has the right direction.
 
Here's the press conference:

[video=youtube;CNXyv0LRRp0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?x-yt-cl=85114404&x-yt-ts=1422579428&v=CNXyv0LRRp0[/video]

He doesn't say a single thing about culture change during the entire thing. Tim Lewieke, however, says plenty about it. He is, thankfully, not part of the Leafs management group.

Importantly, what Shanahan does say is precisely the opposite of the approach of Fletcher and Burke -- he needs to learn, evaluate, etc., before figuring out what needs to be done. He says this over and over again. And, given what has happened since, he's been true to his word.

of course, just because somebody said 'we need to change the culture' and went about it the wrong way doesn't mean that changes shouldn't have been made.

what i don't understand is why people want to continue to entrench this roster. a few years ago they weren't a playoff team but they were young, inexperienced and had some holes. but there is absolutely no excuse for what we've seen this year, and blaming it on the coach is (i) simplistic and (ii) very clearly so, so wrong given what's happened since carlyle was fired.

and so you're left asking what the problem is... and at the end of the day the 5-6 guys who have been together for 4, 5, 6 years are the ones who need to be held accountable. they are no longer young and inexperienced. they even gained some playoff experience. but have sliipped right back into being the 80 point team they were 3 years, 5 years ago, 7 years ago.

enough already.

tell me how keeping iginla around through his 30s worked out for calgary?

this team has had its shot. it's time to make changes.
 
That was almost a year ago, mbow. He's now figuring it out and probably on the same page as you and I are now.
 
Okay, my bad. I too like what he's been doing. The next thing he needs to do is replace the pro scouting, but he's probably leaving that up to Hunter.
 
and blaming it on the coach is (i) simplistic and (ii) very clearly so, so wrong given what's happened since carlyle was fired.

When you say that blaming it on the coach is simplistic, what's your take on the 180 this club has made in possession? When you actually break down what is "so so wrong" since Carlyle got punted, the club is shooting about half of what the lowest team in the league has shot this season (Carolina at 6.5%) while at the same time receiving hilariously bad goaltending for the most part. Before anyone claims this is part of Horachek's system, his Panthers shot 7.2% with way less talent than this group has.

If the Leafs were losing hockey games the same way they were under Randy, I would nod and call it a day, but they're just not. They're losing games that if they continue playing with this possession profile, the won't continue losing shortly.
 
Pretty much totally agree with this.

This team needs to go through a rebuild. I think Shanahan has the patience and vision to do this. I'm very leery of them trading guys for others' prospects and roster players, as Steve Kasper, Penny, Rowie and Watt are still the pro scouting department who have brought us such gems as Clarkson, Bolland, McSelke, Booth, et al. A bit more okay with Mark Hunter heading up that group, but still very nervous about them trading for pros.

If I look at any of the established 25+ year olds on the team, the only ones I'm keen on holding onto are Kessel and Komarov. Even Kessel I'd be okay with unloading if they got a wickedly good return. I'm a bit on the fence about Franson, but he's probably going to demand too much to retain for the rebuild.

That said, there are some good young talented guys on the roster I'd not want to give up on just yet: Kadri, Rielly, Holland, Panik and, yes, Gardiner (!).

The rest ... meh, and a few I'd like to send packing (Phaneuf, Bozak, JVR).

Just like back in the day, we're on the same page here. Go figure!
 
Back
Top