• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

The Breaking Point

I think he was talking about more important reasons, like wins and losses. You know, hockey.

The last Hall of Famer the Leafs drafted was Lanny MacDonald.
 
Not really. Leafs are super popular, regardless of individual star power.

For now. The train could start running out of steam though, there's a lot of angst, anger, etc. People just start turning it off and doing other shit with the time. Especially when they see their basketball team doing well, with the demographics of Toronto, there could be a pretty rapid shift in fan base from one winter sport to the other.

Other NHL markets could desperately use a McDavid to anchor their entire marketing efforts.

This is true, but nowhere would McDavid be bigger. McDavid in blue and white becomes a larger than life hockey icon.
 
Not really. Leafs are super popular, regardless of individual star power.

Other NHL markets could desperately use a McDavid to anchor their entire marketing efforts.

The Oilers are a disaster and that's with drafting almost exclusively in the top 5 since 2007. It's hard to see how McDavid ending up there is a benefit to him or the League.

The Sabres have a good young core developing and would end up with an American star in Eichel or Hanifin anyway.

It's hard, I think, to argue that a marquee talent like McDavid going to Arizona brings more marketing value to the League than having it's next possible generational talent playing for one of it's biggest franchises.
 
For now. The train could start running out of steam though, there's a lot of angst, anger, etc. People just start turning it off and doing other shit with the time. Especially when they see their basketball team doing well, with the demographics of Toronto, there could be a pretty rapid shift in fan base from one winter sport to the other.



This is true, but nowhere would McDavid be bigger. McDavid in blue and white becomes a larger than life hockey icon.

True but irrelevant when you have so many franchises that need McDavid more. If you're Bettman, growing the game a few percentage points in Canada won't add much to the value of the league. There are so many low hanging franchises where a star charismatic player can grow the game exponentially in their sunbelt market.
 
The other simple business move is adding another team to the GTA. Two teams capturing immense GTA demand is better for every team in the league except Leafs, and it won't hurt them nearly as much as it will help the league.
 
True but irrelevant when you have so many franchises that need McDavid more. If you're Bettman, growing the game a few percentage points in Canada won't add much to the value of the league. There are so many low hanging franchises where a star charismatic player can grow the game exponentially in their sunbelt market.

This is the same thinking that caused the roadblocks to Gretzky becoming a Leaf, and instead sending him down to the newly-created LA Kings franchise. It didn't really grow the game much, though, did it? It wasn't until just a few years ago, when the Kings built a fantastic cup-winning team that anybody in LA even cared about hockey.
That thinking is flawed. It always was.
But if Bettman will pull his bullshit again to make sure McDavid goes to some smaller market, we have some other good choices for this team. Max Domi, for example. Won't be as good as McDavid, but a local fan favourite, and good enough to be better than most of the guys we have now.
 
This is the same thinking that caused the roadblocks to Gretzky becoming a Leaf, and instead sending him down to the newly-created LA Kings franchise. It didn't really grow the game much, though, did it? It wasn't until just a few years ago, when the Kings built a fantastic cup-winning team that anybody in LA even cared about hockey.
That thinking is flawed. It always was.
But if Bettman will pull his bullshit again to make sure McDavid goes to some smaller market, we have some other good choices for this team. Max Domi, for example. Won't be as good as McDavid, but a local fan favourite, and good enough to be better than most of the guys we have now.

Forget the conspiracy theories.
Gretzky did help grow the game in California.
Max D has been drafted already.
 
True but irrelevant when you have so many franchises that need McDavid more. If you're Bettman, growing the game a few percentage points in Canada won't add much to the value of the league. There are so many low hanging franchises where a star charismatic player can grow the game exponentially in their sunbelt market.

Has a singular star player ever actually helped a non traditional hockey market grow more than a downtown arena has? Gretzky in LA sure, but outside of that?

Downtown arenas are by far the biggest issue affecting non traditional hockey market and the growth of their fan base and the game. Phoenix has had competitive teams and still couldn't draw flies, Carolina has had one of the league's biggest young stars and couldn't grow a proper hockey culture in Carolina. If arenas are accessible, the people have shown that they'll come.

McDavid in Phoenix or Carolina would do **** all to grow the game in those areas.

Tampa drew 18,600 the year before they drafted Stamkos....the arena is downtown. Carolina got a very modest 10% bump from a ****ing Stanley Cup win, while having one of the best young players in the league at the time.

So what would move the needle more financially for the league, and help grow the game more? McDavid in locations that have proven to be reliant on one major factor, arena location, more than anything else, or causing a ****ing meltdown by giving a massive and very dormant Leaf fan base a reason to start buying stuff again?
 
Last edited:
I haven't been able to find the article, but I read somewhere recently that the HNIC ratings under Rogers thus far have taken a serious dive in comparison even to last year, as have the ratings for Maple Leaf regional games. This is also bleeding into the ratings for any early or late games, as if the regular Leaf-fan viewers aren't tuning in to the Leaf games, they won't be sticking around to watch the late games either, or tuning in early to watch any lead-in afternoon games.

Considering their $6-7 billion investment overall in TV rights and an ownership stake in MLSE, Rogers can't be too pleased. If the Leafs ended up with McDavid though, probably safe to assume that'd result in a pretty large ratings spike, even if the Leafs were rebuilding and in a fight for a playoff spot next year.

Now, I don't really believe in conspiracy theories where the draft lottery is concerned, but if you do like to don tin foil, that's a motive to take into consideration.
 
Gretzky did help grow the game in California.

Not as a 18 yr old draftee he didn't....as well, when he left, attendance figures trended back downward until this recent King's contender team was put together. Attendance in LA trended down into the 15-16K a game range within a few years of Gretzky leaving. That's not growing the game, that's patching the boat.
 
Not as a 18 yr old draftee he didn't....as well, when he left, attendance figures trended back downward until this recent King's contender team was put together. Attendance in LA trended down into the 15-16K a game range within a few years of Gretzky leaving. That's not growing the game, that's patching the boat.

Exactly. It's a ridiculous idea to think a top prospect needs to be placed in a smaller market to "grow the game."
 
I haven't been able to find the article, but I read somewhere recently that the HNIC ratings under Rogers thus far have taken a serious dive in comparison even to last year, as have the ratings for Maple Leaf regional games. This is also bleeding into the ratings for any early or late games, as if the regular Leaf-fan viewers aren't tuning in to the Leaf games, they won't be sticking around to watch the late games either, or tuning in early to watch any lead-in afternoon games.

Considering their $6-7 billion investment overall in TV rights and an ownership stake in MLSE, Rogers can't be too pleased. If the Leafs ended up with McDavid though, probably safe to assume that'd result in a pretty large ratings spike, even if the Leafs were rebuilding and in a fight for a playoff spot next year.

Now, I don't really believe in conspiracy theories where the draft lottery is concerned, but if you do like to don tin foil, that's a motive to take into consideration.

Oh, I don't believe in conspiracy theories either...but there's simply no economic argument for saying that the league is better off with McDavid in Carolina, Phoenix, Florida, etc. McDavid in a Leaf uniform would be a financial phenomena for the league. If growing the game in the US is the desire, then Gary wants Connor in a big American market like NY, Chicago, etc. That national "sportscentre" exposure means a lot more to the growth of the game in the US than McDavid toiling away in the desert for a few years would mean. Yeah, the Yotes might sell an extra 100,000 seats a year at 40 dollars a piece, but that's a ****ing pittance compared to what McDavid is worth in a major market.
 
Not as a 18 yr old draftee he didn't....as well, when he left, attendance figures trended back downward until this recent King's contender team was put together. Attendance in LA trended down into the 15-16K a game range within a few years of Gretzky leaving. That's not growing the game, that's patching the boat.

More and more Californian players are being drafted in the early rounds of the NHL.
 
Exactly. It's a ridiculous idea to think a top prospect needs to be placed in a smaller market to "grow the game."

I'm not saying anyone is "placed". The original argument was that the league should want Connor McDavid in a Leafs jersey. My point is that only Leaf fans want that.
 
Back
Top