From Fred up to the present day, I’ve been pretty close to the #1 hater of our goaltending in the playoffs.
But even I wouldn’t point to any one of our series losses in the Matthews era and claim that our goaltending was THE reason we lost that series.
The issue’s never been catastrophically bad goaltending that single-handed lost us series we were otherwise dominating. It’s been that we’ve consistently had the 2nd (or sometimes 3rd) best goalie in any given series. And some of those goalies have been particularly adept at letting muffins past them at back-breaking times.
Combine that with god fucking awful coaching, not enough offense from our depth forwards & defense, too many shitty plugs, Tavares being incapable of carrying a line, a consistently woeful powerplay, Mitch always pulling a disappearing act by the half point of every series and Matthews never managing to put the team on his back and put up video game scoring numbers like other stars in the playoffs…and you have the toxic brew that’s led to this team being the worst playoff underachievers in modern NHL history.